Chapter 14 · Topic 14.3 · Prelims + Mains3 of 3

Foreign Travellers: Reading travel accounts critically

Key points

  • Using travel accounts critically.

Prelims box: facts and traps

StrengthLimitation
Fresh eyes: note everyday life, prices, roadsLanguage gaps and dependence on interpreters
Compare with other landsBias: judging India by home standards (Bernier)
Independent of court flatteryShort stays; hearsay; love of the marvellous
Describe women, slaves, marketsMostly saw cities and courts, not villages.
  • For Mains-style answers, pair a traveller with a theme: Ibn Battuta for communication and towns, Paes and Nuniz for Vijayanagara's court and women, Bernier for land and the state, Tavernier for crafts and the diamond trade.

Reading travel accounts critically

StrengthLimitation
Fresh eyes: note everyday life, prices, roadsLanguage gaps and dependence on interpreters
Compare with other landsBias: judging India by home standards (Bernier)
Independent of court flatteryShort stays; hearsay; love of the marvellous
Describe women, slaves, marketsMostly saw cities and courts, not villages

For Mains-style answers, pair a traveller with a theme: Ibn Battuta for communication and towns, Paes and Nuniz for Vijayanagara’s court and women, Bernier for land and the state, Tavernier for crafts and the diamond trade. Then add one line on the limits of the source.

Mains box: analysis and answer points

StrengthLimitation
Fresh eyes: note everyday life, prices, roadsLanguage gaps and dependence on interpreters
Compare with other landsBias: judging India by home standards (Bernier)
Independent of court flatteryShort stays; hearsay; love of the marvellous
Describe women, slaves, marketsMostly saw cities and courts, not villages.
  • For Mains-style answers, pair a traveller with a theme: Ibn Battuta for communication and towns, Paes and Nuniz for Vijayanagara's court and women, Bernier for land and the state, Tavernier for crafts and the diamond trade.
  • Likely next angle: Bias and limits

Practice

Prelims PYQs on this topic (1)

UPSC Prelims 2018 · GS Paper I

Which one of the following foreign travellers elaborately discussed about diamonds and diamond mines of India ?

Answer (b) & explanation

Jean-Baptiste Tavernier wrote about diamonds (b). Tavernier was a French jewel merchant who made six trips to India between 1640 and 1667. In his Travels, he described the Golconda diamond mines, such as Kollur on the Krishna, along with how they were mined and traded. He sold the large blue "Tavernier Blue" to Louis XIV; it was later recut into the Hope Diamond. Bernier (a) was a doctor who wrote on Mughal politics and argued there was no private land ownership. Thevenot (c) wrote about western and southern India. Carré (d) wrote on politics and French trade.

Notice the famous Golconda diamonds: the Koh-i-Noor and the Daria-i-Noor.

Answer as per the official UPSC answer key.

Open this question's page →

Write an answer

In 150 words, explain the significance of Foreign Travellers with one recent example.

Flashcards (1)

Main limitation of travel accounts?

Bias, language gaps, short stays.

In the news

Medieval Indian History →All Medieval Indian History topics

Syllabus: Prelims GS-I · History of India and Indian National Movement.

Read these notes on battleias.com