UPSC Mains 2024 GS2 Q3: model answer
“The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the marginalisation of the parliamentary supremacy.” Elucidate.
What the question wants
Show how cabinet dominance weakens Parliament, with evidence, and note the checks that remain.
How to structure it
Intro: In theory the Cabinet is responsible to the Lok Sabha (Art. 75(3)). Body: (1) Signs of marginalisation; (2) Reasons; (3) Checks remain. Conclusion: Parliament is not sovereign in name alone, but its deliberative role has shrunk.
- 1(1) Signs of marginalisation
- 2(2) Reasons
- 3(3) Checks remain
Model answer
In theory the Cabinet is responsible to the Lok Sabha (Art. 75(3)). In practice, a Cabinet with a stable majority controls the House.
Signs of marginalisation
- Fewer sittings: Lok Sabha now meets about 55–70 days a year, against over 120 in the 1950s.
- Fewer Bills sent to committees in recent Lok Sabhas.
- Important Bills passed with little debate or by voice vote amid disruption; use of the Money Bill route (the Aadhaar Act).
- Frequent ordinances.
- Anti-defection law makes MPs follow the party whip on every vote.
- Budgets largely 'guillotined' without discussion of most ministries' grants.
Reasons: strong party discipline, majority governments, weak opposition, technical complexity of laws.
Checks remain
- Question Hour, committees (PAC), no-confidence motions.
- Rajya Sabha where the government lacks a majority.
- Judicial review and media.
Parliament is not sovereign in name alone, but its deliberative role has shrunk. More sitting days, compulsory committee scrutiny and a freer whip would restore balance.
Keywords, cases and data to drop in
collective responsibility executive dominance committee scrutiny ordinances anti-defection whip
Where most answers lose marks
- Not giving evidence.
Same theme in Prelims
Consider the following statements in respect of questions asked by the Members in the Parliament of India :
- 1. Unstarred questions are those to which a Member desires an oral answer in the House.
- 2. Starred questions are those to which a Member desires a written answer.
- 3. No supplementary question can be asked on an unstarred question.
Which one of the following conclusions based on the above statements is correct ?
Answer (c) & explanation
Only one statement is correct (c). Statement 3 is right: an unstarred question gets a written answer, so no supplementary question can follow. Statement 1 is wrong: unstarred questions get written, not oral, answers. Statement 2 is wrong: a starred question, marked with an asterisk, gets an oral answer on the floor, and supplementaries may follow. Statements 1 and 2 swap the two types. So options (a), (b) and (d) fail.
Notice the third type: a short notice question is on a matter of urgent public importance, asked with less than ten days' notice and answered orally. Question Hour is usually the first hour of a sitting, followed by Zero Hour, an Indian innovation not found in the Rules of Procedure.
a clean swap of definitions. Remember: the star is for the spoken answer on the floor.
Answer as per the official UPSC answer key.
Consider the following statements about the Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes of the Parliament of India :
- 1. Although members of this Committee are elected from both Houses of Parliament, the Chairperson of this Committee is appointed by the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
- 2. Twenty members are elected by the Rajya Sabha and ten members by the Lok Sabha.
- 3. No Minister, except for the Union Minister of Social Justice and Empowerment, is eligible to be a member of this Committee.
- 4. Members are elected for a fixed term of two years from the date they enter their office.
Which one of the following conclusions based on the above statements is correct ?
Answer (d) & explanation
No statement is correct (d). The Committee on the Welfare of SCs and STs has 30 members. Statement 1 is wrong: the Speaker appoints its Chairperson from among the Lok Sabha members. Statement 2 is wrong: 20 members come from the Lok Sabha and 10 from the Rajya Sabha, the reverse of the statement. Statement 3 is wrong: no Minister at all can be a member. Statement 4 is wrong: the term is one year, not two. So options (a), (b) and (c) fail.
Notice the pattern: like the Estimates and Public Accounts committees, it is a financial-style committee where Ministers are barred. Its job is to examine the work of the National Commissions for SCs and STs and the implementation of safeguards.
four confident details, all slightly off. When every line has a number or an office, check each one.
Answer as per the official UPSC answer key.
Consider the following statements :
- I. On the dissolution of the House of the People, the Speaker shall not vacate his/her office until immediately before the first meeting of the House of the People after the dissolution.
- II. According to the provisions of the Constitution of India, a Member of the House of the People on being elected as Speaker shall resign from his/her political party immediately.
- III. The Speaker of the House of the People may be removed from his/her office by a resolution of the House of the People passed by a majority of all the then Members of the House, provided that no resolution shall be moved unless at least fourteen days' notice has been given of the intention to move the resolution.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
Answer (c) & explanation
Statements I and III are correct (c). Statement I is right: under Article 94, on dissolution of the Lok Sabha the Speaker stays in office until just before the first meeting of the new House. Statement III is right: the Speaker may be removed by a resolution passed by a majority of all the then members, after at least 14 days' notice. Both lines are copied almost word for word from Article 94. Statement II is wrong: nothing in the Constitution asks the Speaker to leave the party.
Notice that resigning from the party is a convention in Britain, not a rule in India. The Speaker decides defection cases under the Tenth Schedule and certifies Money Bills. The Deputy Speaker post stayed vacant for the whole 17th Lok Sabha.
a good practice dressed as a constitutional rule. Ask, "Which Article says this?"
Fell for this one? Most aspirants do. The PYQ Book puts every UPSC trap side by side, so the pattern finally clicks. Try the free sample
Answer as per the official UPSC answer key.
Fresh examples from current affairs
Monsoon Session ends: 19 sittings, 12 Bills passed by both Houses
The Monsoon Session 2026 of Parliament began on 20 July and was adjourned sine die on 13 August 2026. It had 19 sittings over 25 days. Both Houses passed 12 Bills, including amendments on public examinations, national honour, birth and death registration, MSMEs, tribunals and minerals, and the Bill renaming Kerala as Keralam.
UPSC angle: Prelims: sine die vs prorogation.
13 Aug 2026
MEA Parliament replies (13 Aug 2026): IORA chair
India chairs the Indian Ocean Rim Association for 2025-2027 under the theme "Innovation, Openness, Resilience and Adaptability in the Indian Ocean Region", MEA told Rajya Sabha on 13 August 2026. India hosted the Indian Ocean Dialogue in May 2026, a senior officials' meeting in June and will host the Council of Ministers later this year.
UPSC angle: Prelims: IORA chair 2025-27 and theme. · Mains: India in the Indian Ocean.
13 Aug 2026
MEA Parliament replies (6-7 Aug 2026): Arctic, UNSC seat
In Lok Sabha replies on 7 August 2026, MEA said India's 2022 Arctic Policy, "India and the Arctic: Building a Partnership for Sustainable Development", guides its Nordic ties. Ties were raised to a Green Technology and Innovation Strategic Partnership at the 3rd India-Nordic Summit. On the UNSC, MEA said expansion needs an amendment of the UN Charter.
UPSC angle: Prelims: India's Arctic Policy (2022). · Mains: UNSC reform.
7 Aug 2026
MEA Parliament replies (30-31 Jul 2026): Iran evacuations, Operation Amistad, Chabahar
The External Affairs Ministry answered four questions in Parliament on 30 and 31 July 2026. Operation Amistad sent relief and an Army field hospital to Venezuela after two earthquakes in June. The Tehran embassy helped 2,557 Indians leave Iran by land. India has met its USD 120 million Chabahar commitment, but the US sanctions waiver ended in April.
UPSC angle: Prelims: Operation Amistad (Venezuela, 2026); BHISHM Cube. · Mains: HADR as diplomacy.
31 Jul 2026Learn the concept
Question text as printed in the official UPSC question paper: https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/QP_CSM_2024_GenStud_II_03102024.pdf The model answer is original Battle IAS work; use it to learn structure, not to memorise.